Lancaster County is undeniably the most well-known location to experience Amish culture in Pennsylvania. But many tourists don’t know there’s a strong presence of Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch folk that live beyond Lancaster, in neighboring counties like York, Chester, and Berks.
If you’re interested in exploring an Amish county tour on the other side of the bridge, this guide should help you plan your round trip from Lancaster to York. Follow this route in sequential order if you’re looking to hit all of the locations in a single day trip!
1). Central Market York
Hours: Vary by vendor | Core Hours Tuesday – Thursday: 9 AM – 2 PM | First Fridays: 5 PM – 9 PM | Core Hours Saturday: 9 AM – 2 PM
Located in the heart of York City, the Central Market is home to over 50 different local vendors. They offer a wide range of dining opportunities and other fresh, specialty food, drinks, and goods.
While not technically Amish-owned, there are a small handful of PA Dutch vendors and like-minded small business folks to meet and shop from. And it’s a nice starting point to learn a bit about the community in York, PA!
2). Miller Plant Farm
Hours: Monday – Friday: 9 AM – 6 PM | Saturday: 9 AM – 4 PM
Local farmlands are a large part of Amish county tours, and Miller Plant Farm has played a key role in providing high-quality crop transplants to commercial farmers since 1928. It’s one of York, PA’s oldest farm and garden centers.
What started as a small business with a single greenhouse and 35 acres of land has flourished into a fifth-generation farm, with 30 greenhouses and over 200 acres of land. Today, they serve the commercial and home gardener with 95% home-grown plant varieties that are best-suited for growth in the region.
In 2024, they were named the “Best Garden Center/Nursery in York/Hanover, PA,” so definitely make a stop if you have an interest in agriculture and family-owned businesses.
3). Perrydelle Farm
Hours: Monday – Saturday: 7 AM – 8 PM | Sunday: 11 AM – 6 PM
Perrydelle Farm and Dairy is a family-owned and operated business that sits on over 170 acres of farmland. Since 1963, they’ve dedicated themselves to providing the freshest dairy products for their community.
While milk (whole, 2% and skim) and homemade ice cream are their specialty, guests can also purchase yogurt, butter, cream, and a variety of locally-made PA Dutch and Amish baked goods from their farm store.
Be sure to try a self-guided tour through the bottling plant to see how their milk is gathered, processed, and bottled onsite.
4). The Markets At Shrewsbury
Hours: Thursday: 9 AM – 5 PM | Friday: 9 AM – 6 PM | Saturday: 8 AM – 4 PM
If you’re looking to explore an authentic Amish and PA Dutch farmer’s market in York, PA, the Markets at Shrewsbury is the go-to place to visit. It’s home to over 19 different local merchants, selling everything from Amish produce, meats, and desserts to traditional PA Dutch eateries, canned goods, and other specialty crafts.
Most merchant stands are run by local Amish or PA Dutch families, so while there may be a smaller variety of shopping here than York’s Central Market, The Markets at Shrewsbury offers a more authentic Amish county tour experience.
5). Penn Dutch Structures
Hours: Tuesday – Wednesday: 9 AM – 4 PM | Thursday: 9 AM – 5 PM | Friday: 9 AM – 6 PM | Saturday: 8 AM – 4 PM
If you have an interest in Amish craftsmanship and furniture, you have to stop by Penn Dutch Structures — conveniently located on the same grounds as the Markets at Shrewsbury! They sell an expansive range of products, from large outdoor structures like sheds, detached garages, and barns to smaller entertainment structures like gazebos, lawn furniture, and garden accents.
Even if you have no interest in buying anything, Penn Dutch Structures is a great place to visit to admire the detail and quality that Amish furniture is known for.
