Ruthie’s Amish Bakery opened at The Markets in March 2018 and the reviews for this Amish bakery have been glowing! For made-from-scratch, traditional Amish baked goods, Ruthie’s cannot be beat.
Their incredible selection includes fan-favorites such as homemade breads, sticky buns, and whoopie pies (in several flavors). But that’s only the beginning! You’ll also find cupcakes, muffins, cookies, rolls, Beehive cakes, cheesecakes, pies, donuts, and eclairs. Additionally, most cakes and pies are sold by the whole, half, or quarter. You can also purchase them by the slice.
Whole Pies (9")
Because everyone loves dessert, Ruthie’s also bakes sugar-free pies and cupcakes and a selection of gluten-free bars, whoopie pies, and cakes to meet all dietary needs.
The holidays are our favorite time of year at Ruthie’s! Shop pumpkin rolls, pumpkin pies, pecan pies, traditional sand tarts, and other Christmas cookies.
While most of Ruthie’s products are made from scratch, on-site daily, they do sell many Lancaster County specialties including Pellman’s cheesecakes and donuts glazed and filled on-site. When Ruthie’s Amish Bakery doesn’t make it themselves, they only choose unbeatable brands.
Need something unique or want to order Amish bakery items in large quantities? Ruthie’s takes special orders and is available to create beautiful baked goods for your baby shower, bridal shower, or wedding.